J.J. McCarthy Injury
J.J. McCarthy Hurts Hip on Zack Baun Hit, Returns to Lead Giants Past Eagles 19-11; Eyes Thursday vs. Commanders
New York Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy gave his team a scare on Sunday, Nov. 8, in Philadelphia. He hurt his hip on a hard third-quarter hit from Eagles linebacker Zack Baun, went to the medical tent and then the locker room, and missed one offensive series. Then he came back and helped close out a 19-11 win over the Eagles.
After the game, McCarthy said the hip was “feeling pretty good,” per ProFootballTalk. The question now is a short week: the Giants play the Washington Commanders on Thursday night.
What happened to J.J. McCarthy?
According to the Giants’ official site, McCarthy took a big hit from Baun with 12:02 left in the third quarter at the end of a 3-yard run. Baun hurt his back on the same play, the team said.
CBS Sports described the hit as landing on McCarthy’s side and lower abdomen on a quarterback keeper, with Baun leading with his helmet. McCarthy tried to throw on the sideline, was in obvious pain after his throwing motion, grabbed his side and went to the turf before medical staff helped him, CBS reported. The Giants listed it as a hip injury and initially called him questionable to return.
Before he left, McCarthy had completed 9 of 13 passes for 101 yards, the Giants said. He had also been sacked five times in what was his second straight start for New York.
Did J.J. McCarthy play the rest of the game?
Yes. Jameis Winston, who started four games earlier this season, came in for one series. He completed 6 of 8 passes for 71 yards and threw a touchdown to tight end Isaiah Likely that put the Giants ahead 13-8 with 2:25 left in the third quarter, according to Giants.com.
McCarthy returned on the next possession. ProFootballTalk reported that he led the Giants to two field goals in the fourth quarter, including a drive helped by a key 11-yard run on third down, which suggested he could handle the job physically.
“Football is a physical game, and I can’t thank the training staff enough for helping me get back on the field as fast as possible,” McCarthy said after the game, per ProFootballTalk. He added that he wanted “to feel it out and make sure that I was ready to go full speed” before going back in.
Is J.J. McCarthy hurt for Thursday?
That is not yet clear. McCarthy said the Giants would “do our best to make sure we turn over as fast as possible” and try to get him “as close to 100 percent” as possible for Thursday’s game against the Commanders, according to ProFootballTalk.
No official injury report for that game had been reported in the sources used here, and the team has not given any timeline beyond McCarthy’s own comments. Thursday games leave very little recovery time, so his practice status early in the week will be the first real sign.
Why it matters for the Giants
The quarterback spot has been fragile for New York all season. CBS Sports noted that Jaxson Dart is out for the year with torn knee ligaments suffered in Week 2, and that the Giants traded for McCarthy as a potential season-long answer after he left the Minnesota Vikings. His play since entering a Week 6 loss to the New Orleans Saints and in his first start the next week was a pleasant surprise, CBS said.
McCarthy’s time in Minnesota was interrupted by several injuries, ProFootballTalk noted, which is part of why he said he was eager not to be knocked out of Sunday’s game.
The win kept the Giants atop the NFC East. If the hip were to linger, Winston would be the likely fill-in, as he was on Sunday. For now, both McCarthy and the reports from the game point to a scare rather than a lasting problem, but the team has not confirmed his status for Thursday.
Key facts
- Injury: Hip, per the Giants
- When: Third quarter, 12:02 left, on a hit by Zack Baun
- Missed: One offensive series
- Result: Giants 19, Eagles 11
- Next game: Thursday vs. Washington Commanders
FAQ
What happened to J.J. McCarthy?
He hurt his hip on a hit by Eagles linebacker Zack Baun in the third quarter on Sunday, Nov. 8.
Did J.J. McCarthy play today?
He started, left for one series to be evaluated, and returned to finish the 19-11 win.
Is J.J. McCarthy hurt badly?
He said the hip felt “pretty good” after the game. No formal timeline or injury-report status had been reported as of Monday.
Who replaced McCarthy?
Jameis Winston, who threw a touchdown pass to Isaiah Likely during his one series.
Sources
- Injury Update: QB J.J. McCarthy (hip) returns — New York Giants (Giants.com)
- Giants' J.J. McCarthy returns against Eagles after hip injury sent QB to locker room — CBS Sports
- J.J. McCarthy: Hip feels pretty good, will do my best to be ready for Thursday — NBC Sports (ProFootballTalk)