Cam Skattebo

Cam Skattebo Stayed in His Stance on Jameis Winston's Failed Sneak. John Harbaugh Says That Was the Plan

Illustration of a football line of scrimmage at night with linemen locked together in a short-yardage pile
Illustration (AI-generated)

One short-yardage play from Thursday night is still being picked apart a day later. With the New York Giants protecting a late lead against the Washington Commanders, quarterback Jameis Winston was stuffed on a third-and-1 sneak while running back Cam Skattebo, lined up behind him, stayed in his stance. The Giants punted and went on to lose 24-21.

On Friday, Giants coach John Harbaugh defended Skattebo, saying the running back was never supposed to push on that play.

What happened on the Jameis Winston sneak?

According to ProFootballTalk, the Giants led 21-17 with 3:56 left in the fourth quarter when they faced third-and-1. They sent Winston into the line on a quarterback sneak. A first down would have given New York a strong chance at a long, clock-draining drive.

Instead, Washington stopped Winston short. As he plowed into the line, Skattebo was directly behind him and could have joined the pile to push him forward, PFT reported. He stayed in his stance, and by the time he got involved, the Commanders had already halted Winston’s forward progress.

Football analytics consultant Ryan Paganetti shared a video of the play on X. He wrote that Skattebo stayed in his stance for 1.8 seconds after the snap and did not reach the pile until about 2.8 seconds had passed, according to The Big Lead’s report on Yahoo Sports. “On a play decided by inches, this delay could have been the difference between keeping the ball and giving Washington another chance,” Paganetti wrote.

What did John Harbaugh say about Cam Skattebo?

Harbaugh said the call was a quarterback sneak but not a “tush push,” and that Skattebo had no pushing assignment.

“We had a certain check involved in it, so he wasn’t supposed to be up there pushing. We didn’t call the same [QB sneak] that we’ve been calling,” Harbaugh said, via Pat Leonard of the New York Daily News, as quoted by ProFootballTalk. “What else am I supposed to say? He wasn’t supposed to be up there pushing.”

Why the Giants would not want Skattebo pushing in that spot was unclear, PFT’s Michael David Smith wrote. Skattebo was not asked about the play after the game, according to PFT, and the reports reviewed here did not include any comment from him.

How did the sneak lead to the Giants’ loss?

After the failed third down, the Giants punted. Washington came back to win 24-21.

The Big Lead reported that New York finished the game with two three-and-outs and an interception, and criticized Harbaugh for punting from the Commanders’ 41-yard line, which set up Washington’s game-winning drive. The outlet also noted the drive included Winston’s fake hard count, in which he yelled “Who let the dogs out,” a moment that drew far more attention than the sneak at first.

Should the Giants have just handed it to Skattebo?

That is the question some critics are asking. Skattebo had gained five and four yards on the first two plays of that drive to set up the third-and-1, according to The Big Lead. The outlet reported he averaged 4.3 yards on 18 carries and scored two touchdowns in the game.

PFT called the sneak a “bizarre play” at a time when every NFL team understands the value of teammates pushing the quarterback forward on sneaks. Harbaugh’s explanation, that the play was a different version of the sneak, offers a reason Skattebo held back, but it does not explain why the Giants chose that call in that moment. Harbaugh did not elaborate on the check, based on the reporting available.

Who is Cameron Skattebo?

Cameron “Cam” Skattebo is a Giants running back whom The Big Lead described as a “battering ram of a tailback,” which is part of why the image of him standing still behind the pile stood out. On Thursday, he was one of the most productive players on the field for New York, with two touchdowns, according to The Big Lead.

What’s next for the Giants?

The loss and the late-game decisions will likely keep Harbaugh’s play-calling under scrutiny. The details of the “check” he described, and whether the Giants change their short-yardage approach, remain to be seen.

FAQ

Why didn’t Cam Skattebo push Jameis Winston on the sneak?

John Harbaugh said Skattebo was not supposed to push because the Giants used a different sneak with a check, not their usual “tush push.”

What was the situation?

Third-and-1, Giants leading 21-17, with 3:56 left in the fourth quarter, according to ProFootballTalk.

What happened after the sneak failed?

The Giants punted, and the Commanders came back to win 24-21.

How did Skattebo play overall?

He ran 18 times at 4.3 yards per carry with two touchdowns, according to The Big Lead.

Sources