USC vs. South Carolina

USC vs. South Carolina: Dawn Staley's Late Challenge Was 'the Play of the Game,' and Lindsay Gottlieb Wants Answers

Illustration of a women's basketball player leaping to block a layup near the rim in a packed arena, figures seen from behind and blurred
Illustration (AI-generated)

No. 1 South Carolina’s 89-85 win over No. 3 USC on Sunday in Greenville came down to one sequence in the final 15 seconds, and a day later, that sequence is what everyone is talking about. Dawn Staley called her challenge “the play of the game.” USC coach Lindsay Gottlieb said she wanted someone to explain the rules to her.

Tessa Johnson scored a career-high 28 points for South Carolina (4-0), and JuJu Watkins had 25 for USC (3-1), as we covered in our game recap. Here is what’s new from the postgame reaction.

The block, the call and the challenge

With South Carolina up 87-85 and 15 seconds left, Gamecocks guard Jordan Lee chased down Watkins on a fast break and blocked her layup. The ball was ruled out of bounds off Lee, giving USC possession, and Gottlieb called timeout to draw up a play, the Greenville News reported.

During that timeout, South Carolina video coordinator Hudson Jacobs told Staley he thought the ball last touched Watkins. Staley challenged, and the call was overturned.

“I got word that we should challenge, and we challenged in that moment, and it was truly the play of the game,” Staley said. She said her worry was a USC 3-pointer: “I’m thinking, ‘Prevent threes.’ I’m thinking (about) seeing the three go in, and then we lose the lead.”

Instead, Johnson was fouled and made both free throws. Asked if she was nervous, Johnson said, “Not really. I feel like I just had to take some deep breaths and basically just do my routine.”

How Jordan Lee nearly took the blame

The Greenville News noted that Lee, a Texas transfer, nearly took the blame. USC’s Jazzy Davidson had stolen the ball from her moments earlier, and the ball went from Davidson to Sara Okeke to Watkins before Lee recovered in time to make the block.

“Jordan made the spectacular play,” Staley said. “She stayed with it. I think she was behind the play, and our expectation is for her to do that because she is such an elite defender.”

Gottlieb’s timeout question

Gottlieb’s issue was not just the call. USC was still charged with the timeout it took before Staley’s challenge. It was the Trojans’ last one, which they likely would have used after Johnson’s free throws, according to the Greenville News.

“I’m unclear when I called the timeout, that they’re allowed to review, and it still costs me the timeout,” Gottlieb said. “If anyone has the answer on that, I’d like to know.”

The Greenville News reported that a timeout is not required to make an appeal, and NCAA rules do not specifically say a timeout must be returned once it has been granted.

Gottlieb also questioned whether the replay was conclusive enough. “The call was made for our ball out of bounds, so it has to be overwhelmingly conclusive to go the other way,” she said. “It was close. It was really close.”

Watkins: ‘That’s on me’

Watkins declined to argue the call. “To me, it doesn’t matter,” she said. “I think that’s on me… What happened, happened, and we just move on.”

What’s next

South Carolina hosts Florida Gulf Coast on Tuesday, Nov. 17, at 7 p.m. ET at Colonial Life Arena in Columbia, according to NCAA.com. USC plays Baylor in the Hollywood Hardwood Classic on Friday, Nov. 20, at Intuit Dome in Inglewood, California.

FAQ

Who won USC vs. South Carolina?

South Carolina, 89-85, on Sunday, Nov. 15.

What was the overturned call?

After Jordan Lee blocked JuJu Watkins with 15 seconds left, the ball was ruled out of bounds off Lee. A South Carolina challenge reversed it, giving the Gamecocks possession.

Did USC get its timeout back?

No. Gottlieb said USC was still charged with the timeout and questioned the rule.

When does South Carolina play next?

Tuesday, Nov. 17, against Florida Gulf Coast.

Earlier coverage: No. 1 South Carolina Holds Off No. 3 USC 89-85 as Tessa Johnson Scores 28, JuJu Watkins Rally Falls Short (Nov 15)

Related topics

Sources